• Welcome to the ShrimperZone forums.
    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which only gives you limited access.

    Existing Users:.
    Please log-in using your existing username and password. If you have any problems, please see below.

    New Users:
    Join our free community now and gain access to post topics, communicate privately with other members, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and free. Click here to join.

    Fans from other clubs
    We welcome and appreciate supporters from other clubs who wish to engage in sensible discussion. Please feel free to join as above but understand that this is a moderated site and those who cannot play nicely will be quickly removed.

    Assistance Required
    For help with the registration process or accessing your account, please send a note using the Contact us link in the footer, please include your account name. We can then provide you with a new password and verification to get you on the site.

Mick

Life President
Joined
Oct 28, 2003
Messages
10,936
As you will be aware, this year sees the advent of SG2 - a further tranche of 18 full-time referees who will referee mainly Championship matches.

Saturday's referee must be one of the best of the rest based on previous performances and may well have turned down an offer of full-time refereeing. He is the usually very decent Dean Whitestone from Northampton, in his eleventh season as a Football League referee. He is a referee we have seen a lot of at Roots Hall but not that much away from home. A goalkeeper in his playing days, he is an officer in the Metropolitan Police.

He started off this season with our curtain raiser against Gillingham. Two cautions for them, none for us and his performance was better than ours.

Before that his last visit to Roots Hall was back in March against Gillingham again. A reasonable performance cautioning 4 Gills and Ben Coker (on the say so of an Assistant). Some thought he was somewhat generous to their no 11, McGlashen, who was eventually subbed after receiving an overdue caution.

His previous match before that at Roots Hall was not his best. It was last season's home defeat against Shrewsbury when he cautioned Rea and three of theirs. Main talking point was whether a red card should have been shown for DOGSO, I wouldn't say he got it wrong.

Before that, his last Southend appointment was a first rate performance in the televised match against Oxford in 2013/14. He let the game flow well, no cards, gave us a penalty and we won 3-0 .... what more could you want?

The previous Southend match was the away match back in January of the same season, the first match in our winless run of twelve League matches, when we drew 1-1 at Dagenham. A yellow for Prosser and three of theirs. Having started our winless League run, he did the decent thing and ended it too with that Oxford game.

Before that he was at Roots Hall for the match in 2012/13 when the fans helped clear snow from the pitch and were rewarded with an abject 3-1 home defeat against Wimbledon. He did fine though with, once again, a yellow for Prosser and three of theirs.

Then another excellent performance in the home Cup game against Brentford. Just the one yellow for Woodyard.

Previously, came the game at Shrewsbury in 2011/12, a match which for me, more than any other, cost us promotion. A match that was there for the taking after an early home dismissal. He also cautioned Timlin and Dickinson and their keeper in a strong refereeing performance.

Other matches at Roots Hall include two visits in 2010/11 for the league win against Torquay and the Cup replay with Macclesfield (just 2 and 3 cautions respectively). The season before that saw two visits also. Firstly, the Friday night 0-0 draw with Millwall, when he did pretty well in the face of some uncompromising football from the visitors; he cautioned 5 of theirs and a couple of ours. He also did the home 1-1 draw with Wycombe, cautioning 3 of theirs and one of ours.

Prior to that were in 2008/9 for the opening game win over Peterborough (when three visitors were cautioned) and later that season against Tranmere when we won 2-1 (again three visitors were cautioned). Before that was the 1-0 defeat against Carlisle the previous season in which his performance was probably better than the 8 cautions might imply. His other visit was in 2006/7 when he officiated in the Leicester home draw in which he sent off Richie Foran. Previously to that, in the same season, he was in charge of the away draw at Coventry which I believe he refereed reasonably well.

He had a spell in the "talent group" and used to get plenty of Championship appointments. His card count is usually the right side of average as it again this season with 58 yellows from 23 games. No reds thus far, in fact no reds since 21 months ago when he showed 2 in the same match.

Assisting will be regular visitors, Ian Cooper from Rochester and Ashvin Degnarain from London.

Neil Hair from Peterborough completes the team as Fourth Official.
 
Marvellous stuff Mick.

He's going to be disappointed when he turns up with the name 'Prosser' already written in his book to find out he no longer plays for us :'(
 
Thought the ref today was pretty good. Just let the game flow and was fair to both sides.
 
Thought all three worked well as a team, they were pretty much on the money in the decision making stakes and as a result probably the best I have seen at the Hall this season.
 
He should've booked their no21 with his foul on Timlin and how thier guy who rugby tackled McLaughlin who would've been on his way towards goal didn't get booked god knows!!!
 
One of the tackles on McL in the second half, their fella was booked for.

The other one, there wasn't a yellow shown, which I thought was a 50/50 call, but would have understood if a yellow was given.

In general, I like referees to keep the cards in their pocket and let some strong challenges go and keep the game flowing. In that respect, he was really good.
 
With my old assessors head on.

Just because a referee doesn't show a card does not necessarily make for a decent performance. The late tackle by their 27 (or 21) early in the second half on Timlin was a caution all day long. Every day. Every game. He didn't do it. Players know this. They know when something happens and a card should be shown. As a result we had a scuffle in front of the benches a few moments later and then Timms flattened him (and in my mind showed intent before deciding it wasn't a good idea and pulled his elbow down). He then got the crowd on his back until he finally produced a card for a tackle that was nowhere near as the one he didn't punish.

All would have been avoided if he'd done what he should have done in the first place and get a yellow out.

Shame really, because aside from that, he was pretty good.
 
With my old assessors head on.

Just because a referee doesn't show a card does not necessarily make for a decent performance. The late tackle by their 27 (or 21) early in the second half on Timlin was a caution all day long. Every day. Every game. He didn't do it. Players know this. They know when something happens and a card should be shown. As a result we had a scuffle in front of the benches a few moments later and then Timms flattened him (and in my mind showed intent before deciding it wasn't a good idea and pulled his elbow down). He then got the crowd on his back until he finally produced a card for a tackle that was nowhere near as the one he didn't punish.

All would have been avoided if he'd done what he should have done in the first place and get a yellow out.

Shame really, because aside from that, he was pretty good.

absolutely spot on. Amazed that and the rugby tackle went unpunished. Stonewall yellows in any game
 
He was fine until he made a bad decision in added time in the first half but he lost the plot for 20 mins and it literally took a challenge that could have been a red to finally get his yellows out! After that he didn't do much wrong but he lost control of the game for a while!
 
Back
Top