• Welcome to the ShrimperZone forums.
    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which only gives you limited access.

    Existing Users:.
    Please log-in using your existing username and password. If you have any problems, please see below.

    New Users:
    Join our free community now and gain access to post topics, communicate privately with other members, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and free. Click here to join.

    Fans from other clubs
    We welcome and appreciate supporters from other clubs who wish to engage in sensible discussion. Please feel free to join as above but understand that this is a moderated site and those who cannot play nicely will be quickly removed.

    Assistance Required
    For help with the registration process or accessing your account, please send a note using the Contact us link in the footer, please include your account name. We can then provide you with a new password and verification to get you on the site.

Mick

Life President
Joined
Oct 28, 2003
Messages
10,953
The four recent home matches against Accrington have been tight affairs with a 1-0 win apiece and two draws. This is in stark contrast to our other two home matches against them, in the late 50s, just after the abolition of Divs 3 North and South, which we won by an aggregate of 10-3.

Saturday's match official is the experienced and normally very decent Mick Russell from St Albans.

A steady official in his 11th season (although he has had a few lengthy spells out with injuries), this will be his 14th Southend match and his 8th at home.

His first home Southend match was also Freddie Eastwood's first match and we know what happened there! His next home game was the early season victory over Stoke in 2006/7. Some more recent home matches were the 3-3 derby match with Colchester when he cautioned 5 of theirs and none of ours and the somewhat lively 3-2 victory over a fairly unpleasant Hartlepool side involving two penalties and the dismissal of their keeper.

He most recent Southend home match was on our march to Wembley with our home win over a less than full strength Brentford team (cautioned Timlin and a couple of theirs). Before that four seasons ago at home to Morecambe, where some might say he wasn't great and failed to dismiss a Morecambe player for an off the ball incident involving Mohsni and, later in the same season, when he (and we) coasted through a cardless game against Macclesfield (Mohsni got a couple).

His first two away matches were both on the south coast; the 1-1 draw at Bournemouth when Sodje was injured and then the 3-2 defeat at Brighton in 2007/8.

Then comes the match when he apparently blotted his copybook in a game I did not see at Swindon in 2009/10, where, by all accounts, he had a bit of a nightmare. However he was subsequently back to his best in a game I did see at Norwich later that season when it was certainly not his fault we failed to hold on to one point when for much of the game we looked like taking all three.

Next away game was the 2011/12 win at Burton where he had another good match, although he did caution Grant and Phillips. Then his most recent away match was Straker's finest hour - the Cup win at Chesterfield last season with yellows to Coker, Hurst and one of theirs.

A referee who usually officiates with a smile on his face, he looks to allow play to continue where possible and always has a below average card count. He has done 21 matches this season which have produced 54 yellows and 3 reds (9 of those yellows came in the Leeds/Derby match).

His assistants are the incredibly short Matthew Buonassisi (né McLaughlin) from Bedford who can have a tendency to be a bit "busier" with the flag than always necessary and Mark Mellor from Hemel Hempstead. Neil Hair from Peterborough is on 4th Official duty.
 
He is also one of just four referees who have not awarded a single penalty kick so far this season !
 
He is also one of just four referees who have not awarded a single penalty kick so far this season !

Like our home win on a Tuesday that will have to change one day, lets hope if Saturday he gives it the right way!
 
Whoops, just realised I have gone off thread, which is something I have moaned about in the past:Worthy:
 
well, another poor official. when it was said on the original post that he likes to let the game flow, i didnt realise that included when all sorts of fouls were going on. also, where it says he has a less than average card count, we also saw why today... he ignores all the fouls...
 
He missed so many blatant pushes in and around the box today. He awarded a goal kick after Worrall's left foot shot deflected behind and looked totally bemused when surrounded by several players, and even more so when their full-back appeared to admit it came off him.
 
He was poor today, missed some obvious stuff, got a couple of easy decisions wrong, and was generally poor for both sides. But..... whatever way you look at it, its not his fault we lost.
 
Worst ref this season. We'll certainly the most inconsistent. Seemed unable to understand the game or have any influence in it.
 
He was poor today, missed some obvious stuff, got a couple of easy decisions wrong, and was generally poor for both sides. But..... whatever way you look at it, its not his fault we lost.

True. But it's his fault we weren't awarded a penalty for a clear handball in the area.
 
True. But it's his fault we weren't awarded a penalty for a clear handball in the area.

Or the one in the second half, where the guys climbed all over Thompson.

No wonder the guy hadn't given a penalty yet, he had no idea what a foul was!!

However surely the lino saw that handball as well.
 
The officials were awful, just awful. Inconsistency, poor decisions and didn't see many of the glaringly obvious fouls and handballs.
 
Or the one in the second half, where the guys climbed all over Thompson.

No wonder the guy hadn't given a penalty yet, he had no idea what a foul was!!

However surely the lino saw that handball as well.

Thompson was telling the ref at a corner that the player had both arms around him. The player backed off and as soon as the ref stepoped back a yard and the corner was taken, their player put both arms round Thompson right in front of the ref. Thompson couldn't move, a clear penalty for me for a foul
 
this ref was terrible, what can clubs do ?

He got so much wrong.

i don't blame a stanley, if you know the ref is going to let you get away with it, take advantage
 
Refs and linesman have a diffulcult job at the best of times,they give decisions in a mili second whilst players try to con them !

I thought they all did their job on Saturday,nothing special but Defo not as bad as some say Imo.
 
Back
Top