Question Centre Back Solution, knee jerk reaction or the ramblings of a madman?

[The Eternal Optimist]

If Bilel Mohsni was available to fill in at centre back would you welcome him back?

1) Yes, welcome back Bilel all is forgiven
2) Yes, but only on a short term deal to get us out of a hole :thumbsup:
3) No, we are not at rock bottom just yet :stunned:
4) No, no, no, keep that maniac away from the club! :punch:
5) Feel free to add your own answer (keep it clean please :censored: :winking:)

 

[The Eternal Optimist]

I'll start off by going for:

2) Yes, but only on a short term deal to get us out of a hole

I don't think he is a total waste of time. 100% Passion, 100% Unpredictability, 100% Folk Hero, 100% Nutter

 

[TTS]

Hang on , wouldn't PB play him in midfield any way

Brown Out !

 

[Sussex Shrimper]

He could benefit from the experienced and calming presence of Anton, a man who you'd never see sprint to get himself involved in a brawl.

 

[OldBlueLady]

On a short term deal in a heart beat! I think there are people in the team from whom he would really benefit.

 

[Lord Football]

No. Not good enough for this level.

 

[THE SEVENTIES NORTH BANK]

Well last time he fell out with some team mates, at training, in the dressing room, and on the coach home. The crazy sending's off. The scissors incident. It's a nice environment in the squad at the moment I have heard. So no thanks.(Good player tho).

 

[NZamba Legend]

At this stage would you take back Carl Beeston to fill the CM slot? I would.

 

[BrettieAngell]

No thankyou.

 

[rlb999]

What a daft post. Mohsni wasn't guaranteed his place in the league below, and we could easily go White & Ferdinand for the first few games without it representing a serious weakness. Equally we could get a loan in by tea time - like we did with Chris Walton.

 

[Jay_SUFC]

Not in a million years!!

 

[Shrimperforlife]

What a daft post. .

aren't most posts on here?

 

[MK Shrimper]

Yeah I'm sure he's a nice bloke off the pitch and a definite talent, but he's clearly a huge disruptive influence. Not a good thing in a team sport and I hope we never see him in a blue or orange shirt ever again.

 

[The Eternal Optimist]

What a daft post. Mohsni wasn't guaranteed his place in the league below, and we could easily go White & Ferdinand for the first few games without it representing a serious weakness. Equally we could get a loan in by tea time - like we did with Chris Walton.

I personally think Mohsni if better at Centre Back than White and much more physical, better in the air but of course is as mad as a brush. If he could stay on the pitch, he'd undoubtedly carry a goal threat (ours not theirs).

 

[Kevin Hogg]

5
His ability is vastly exaggerated.
His arrogance...is not.

 

[tommy tucker]

Have a bad feeling about this so called centre back from a scotish prem club .I just cant see anyone coming in before Friday to able to play against Blackburn in day after . So it looks as if we will be going into the match with a patched up team .

 

[amsemp]

Nope not for me.

In such a close knit squad ahead of an important season, the last thing we need is Mohsni upsetting the balance, getting sent off, falling out with people, being disruptive and generally being Bilel Mohsni.

 

[fbm]

Never have I seen a player more passionate and driven to win every ball, almost tackling with every part of his body.

He has scored two of the best goals I have ever seen at the Hall; a thunderbolt header from the edge of the box v Accrington to win us a point and an absolute thunderbolt of a shot into the top corner from about 35-40 yards v Northampton.

He was a real fans favourite.

I have also never seen a bigger liability on a football pitch, or, if you consider post match behaviour, off it as well.

His time has been and gone, no way would he enhance the squad.

Not a solution in any position.

 

[Streaky]

V). I think I would prefer 53 year old Rob Newman.

 

[MK Shrimper]

V). I think I would prefer 53 year old Rob Newman.

With David Baddiel on the left? :unsure: