• Welcome to the ShrimperZone forums.
    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which only gives you limited access.

    Existing Users:.
    Please log-in using your existing username and password. If you have any problems, please see below.

    New Users:
    Join our free community now and gain access to post topics, communicate privately with other members, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and free. Click here to join.

    Fans from other clubs
    We welcome and appreciate supporters from other clubs who wish to engage in sensible discussion. Please feel free to join as above but understand that this is a moderated site and those who cannot play nicely will be quickly removed.

    Assistance Required
    For help with the registration process or accessing your account, please send a note using the Contact us link in the footer, please include your account name. We can then provide you with a new password and verification to get you on the site.

Slipperduke

The Camden Cad
Joined
Aug 24, 2004
Messages
4,333
Location
North London
Have you noticed anything strange about this transfer window? Usually by this stage of the summer the Premier League is awash with new superstars from every corner of the planet, all clutching whopping great contracts and glibly swearing their allegiance to the cause, but with the exception of Yuri Zhirkov, there hasn't been a single big-name foreign signing. In fact, the summer's second biggest import after the Russian left-back is Thomas Vermaelen, Arsenal's new Belgian defender. Players are still changing hands domestically, but the rush of imports has dried up. More worryingly, anyone who's anyone is heading off to La Liga. Is it the prospect of a less punishing campaign or more skillful football that's dragging them there? Of course not. It's money.

Jermaine Pennant's release from Liverpool may not have surprised anyone, but when he went on to sign for Real Zaragoza last week every football agent in the country sat up and took notice. Pennant has managed to land himself a deal that will see him take home more money than his close friend Ashley Cole does at Chelsea and, for that, he can thank British Prime Minister Gordon Brown.

It was Brown who introduced a new band of super tax this year that has hit the country's highest earners like a sledgehammer. When Cole picks up his wage slip, he'll note with sadness that precisely half of his wages are siphoned off to the Inland Revenue. Not so for Pennant. The Spanish government, in an effort to attract overseas executives to the country, has a five year tax ceiling of 23% for foreigners. Real Madrid, never slow to miss a trick, successfully argued for the clause to be applied to football in what is affectionately known as the 'Beckham Law'.

For Pennant, a winger whose crossing can best be described as 'vague', to earn as much in England as he will in Spain, he would have to sign an GBP80,000 a week contract with someone and even Manchester City aren't that daft. In Spain he'll earn less, but keep more. It's little wonder that no-one seems to want to play in England at the moment. Pennant may be the first to take advantage, but I bet he won't be the last.

Karim Benzema was thought to be at the top of Sir Alex Ferguson's shortlist, but when you see how much he'll pick up at Real Madrid, it's not hard to understand why he decided to give Manchester a miss. For him to keep as much money as he will in Spain, United would have to pay him over GBP230,000 a week, twice what they were paying Cristiano Ronaldo. Incidentally, this does at least explain why the Portuguese superstar was so eager to 'experience new challenges', doesn't it?

The talent drain will continue for as long as the higher rate of tax remains in place and there's no indication that anything will change in the near-future. Even the opposition Conservative party are reluctant to make any promises of a reversal, fearful that they will branded as the party of the rich. For a country still fighting expensive military campaigns while struggling to break free of the credit crunch, increased revenues are more vital than ever.

English football clubs have dominated Europe for the past five years, propelled to success by expensively assembled, star-studded squads, but all that could come to an end if the balance of power continues to shift towards Spain. Keep your eye on that transfer market, but don't hold your breath. There won't be many big foreign signings this summer.





NAME WEEKLY PAY (GBP) WEEKLY TAKE-HOME (GBP)

Karim Benzema 150,000 115,500
Jermaine Pennant 52,000 40,000

Ashley Cole 75,000 37,500

All figures are estimates based on reported figures
 
The talent drain will continue for as long as the higher rate of tax remains in place

I should also have thought that the fact that Sterling is ranked at the moment only slightly ahead of the Turkish Lira and Zimbabwean Dollar is playing a very significant part in all of this. We've gone from £1 = €1.4 to about £1 = €1.15 this year. It's painful enough for mere mortals like us when you're buying beer in Benidorm, but as soon as you're into footballers' wages, it hurts way more than Brown's tax plans.

So, a weekly wage of £60,000 a week translated into €84,000 last year. That's now only worth €69,000 this year - or €15,000 less per week.

That's €780,000 less over the course of the year... a far more painful cut than Gordy's tax take (which hasn't even kicked in yet).

When Sterling's strong, we get loads of Jonny Foreigners coming over to cash in; when it's weak, they all stay away.

Matt
 
Interesting piece.

I don't imagine that I'm alone in welcoming this development in football (politics/economics is another matter), as it can only be good news for our international side. With this being a world cup year, I'll be cheering on the opposition for the nominally English sides in the Fourth and Upwards Cup Knockout European Revenue Sharing League. Let's see the likes of Ferdinand, Rooney, Lampard and A. Cole not waste their energy on mickey mouse European competitions when there is the bigger prize of a World Cup waiting for us.

I also hope that more English players opt to experience playing in foreign leagues. I was a little surprised to see not just Pennant go to real Sociedad, but also Matt Derbyshire to some Greek team. I don't think either players are top drawer prospects but maybe playing abroard will help improve them as players. Worryingly Derbyshire must be somewhere near the top of the list of English strikers, given our paucity of attacking options. I'd love to see players like David Bentley, Ben Foster, Aaron Lennon and Tom Huddlestone opt to play abroad in a bid to improve themselves as players.
 
may actually see some the emergence of some young english players that all these academies are supposed to produce, the mass influx of overseas players has certainly IMO effected the National tam, in fact for any country to have less players of their own nationality playing than overseas must be pretty unique, shock horror arsenal may even buy an english player
 
Trust Real Madrid, Darling of the Spanish Royal Family, to introduce something to benefit themselves with complete disregard to how it affects football on an international scale.
 
Back
Top