• Welcome to the ShrimperZone forums.
    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which only gives you limited access.

    Existing Users:.
    Please log-in using your existing username and password. If you have any problems, please see below.

    New Users:
    Join our free community now and gain access to post topics, communicate privately with other members, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and free. Click here to join.

    Fans from other clubs
    We welcome and appreciate supporters from other clubs who wish to engage in sensible discussion. Please feel free to join as above but understand that this is a moderated site and those who cannot play nicely will be quickly removed.

    Assistance Required
    For help with the registration process or accessing your account, please send a note using the Contact us link in the footer, please include your account name. We can then provide you with a new password and verification to get you on the site.

Slipperduke

The Camden Cad
Joined
Aug 24, 2004
Messages
4,333
Location
North London
Brazil 4-3 Egypt

Kaka 5, 90 Zidan 8, 58
Fabiano 12 Shawkey 57
Juan 37

Now this is much more like it. After an insipid first day offered up only an uncomfortable mismatch and a desperately dull bore-draw, day two of the Confederations Cup finally delivered some excitement. Brazil were stifled and surprised by their Egyptian opponents who refused to give up on a game that appeared to be over by half-time. But their victory was delivered not by Kaka or Robinho or Elano or any of the other blue-chip stars in the bright yellow shirts. It was the English referee Howard Webb who saved the day.

It seems that FIFA, unofficially at least, are now using video technology in their tournaments. Just as Zindine Zidane was sent off after the unprecedented intervention of the fifth official, Brazil received an injury time penalty after someone passed word to Webb that an offence had been committed. A late shot, fired in on Egypt's goal, was handled on the line by Ahmed Al Muhamadi, who craftily fell to the ground clutching his face. Webb gave a corner and wandered over to Al Muhamadi, presumably to check the staus of his facial injury. Then, as enraged Brazilian footballers scrambled around him, he put a finger to his earpiece and listened. There is only one televisual feed in the Confederations Cup, as in most competitions, and everyone gets it at the same time. As slow motion footage shamed the nefarious Al Muhamadi, Webb continued to listen. Having apparently been given the verdict from the sidelines, he proceeded to pull out a red card, dismiss the Egyptian and award the penalty to Brazil. Kaka did not need to be asked twice.

Scorned by some as makeweights in this tournament, Egypt are clearly nobody's fools. They may be making hard work of qualification for next year's World Cup, but not for nothing has Hassan Shehata led his team to two successive African Nations triumphs. Even without the injured Amr Zaki and the banished Mido, they still had enough quality to cause Brazil problems, particularly when Mohammed Abo Terika and Mohammed Zidan combined. It was through this partnership that Egypt forged their first and third equalisers, both put away by Zidan. Inbetween those strikes , an uncharacteristically spicy Mohammed Shawkey fired a ripsnorter from the edge of the box that gave Julio Cesar no chance at all. At times, their movement and endeavour was more Brazilian than anything that the Brazilians could offer.

Brazil tend to be the kind of side that you associate with silky, inventive football, but it was their ability to make the best of set-pieces that served them here. A corner and a free-kick from Manchester City's Elano were accurate enough to enable Luis Fabiano and Juan to get onto the scoresheet as well as providing compelling evidence that their sometimes beleaguered manager Dunga is continuing to emphasise simple virtues above the spectacular. Unfortunately, the same problems remain with this side and they should have been all too obvious to him as he watched in horror from the dugout, clad in a terrifyingly fluffy polo neck that struggled all afternoon to free itself from his black blazer.

Brazil won this competition in 2005, but it proved to be no omen of success. They were miserable in Germany, tired and unwilling, their exit typified by Roberto Carlos' failure to even attempt to mark Thierry Henry at the crucual set-piece. There are times when they fail to track back, forget to stick to their runners and gradually ease off from the pressing and containing that is so vital in modern football. Perhaps it is simply a case of fatigue in overworked superstars who would much rather be relaxing on the beach rather than busting their humps for the umpteenth time of asking, but for them to have a chance of winning the World Cup next summer, they must improve their work-rate. They won't always have Webb and his off-screen assistants to rescue them.

MATCH STATS

Crowd -
Yellow Cards - Moawad (Egypt)
Red Cards - Al-Muhamadi (Egypt)
Brazil -
Julio Cesar 7, Lucio 7, Juan 7, Felipe Melo 6, Kleber 7 (Andros Santos 6, 83rd), Elano 7 (Ramieres 6, 63rd), Gilberto Silva 6, Luis Fabiano 7, Kaka 7, Robinho 6 (Alexander Pato 6, 63rd), Dani Alves 6
Egypt -
Essam El Hadary 6, Ahmed Said 6, Hani Said 7, Ahmed Fathi 7, Hosni Abd Rabo 7 (Ahmed Al Muhamadi 6, 75th), Mohammed Zidan 8, Mohammed Shawkey 7, Sayed Moawad 6, Ahmed Hassan 6 (Ahmed Eid, 51st), Wael Gomaa 6, Mohamed Abo Terika 8
 
It seems that FIFA, unofficially at least, are now using video technology in their tournaments. Just as Zindine Zidane was sent off after the unprecedented intervention of the fifth official, Brazil received an injury time penalty after someone passed word to Webb that an offence had been committed. A late shot, fired in on Egypt's goal, was handled on the line by Ahmed Al Muhamadi, who craftily fell to the ground clutching his face. Webb gave a corner and wandered over to Al Muhamadi, presumably to check the staus of his facial injury. Then, as enraged Brazilian footballers scrambled around him, he put a finger to his earpiece and listened. There is only one televisual feed in the Confederations Cup, as in most competitions, and everyone gets it at the same time. As slow motion footage shamed the nefarious Al Muhamadi, Webb continued to listen. Having apparently been given the verdict from the sidelines, he proceeded to pull out a red card, dismiss the Egyptian and award the penalty to Brazil. Kaka did not need to be asked twice.

Ive not seen the footage yet but I think this is not a particularly welcome developmet if it's true. Unless it's done openly and across the board Id rather leave it down to the ref and assistants. Otherwise it will just leave it open for accusations when things are missed.

As a neutral my enjoyment is often enhanced by referee errors....how great it would have been if ZZ's headbutt went unnoticed, or the Egyptian got away with the handball.

What Id prefer is better use of disciplinary panels reviewing matches and dishing out harsh penalties to those who have tried to con the ref (eg Egyptian player / Ronaldo's diving etc), so that the cheating is cut out in the first instance.
 
Back
Top