• Welcome to the ShrimperZone forums.
    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which only gives you limited access.

    Existing Users:.
    Please log-in using your existing username and password. If you have any problems, please see below.

    New Users:
    Join our free community now and gain access to post topics, communicate privately with other members, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and free. Click here to join.

    Fans from other clubs
    We welcome and appreciate supporters from other clubs who wish to engage in sensible discussion. Please feel free to join as above but understand that this is a moderated site and those who cannot play nicely will be quickly removed.

    Assistance Required
    For help with the registration process or accessing your account, please send a note using the Contact us link in the footer, please include your account name. We can then provide you with a new password and verification to get you on the site.

Yorkshire Blue

Super Moderator⭐
Staff member
Joined
Oct 27, 2003
Messages
41,066
Location
London
As uninspiring as England v NZ (again) is, West Indies v Australia produced some enthralling play to show that it is England who are short of inspiration, not the format or the sport.

Two years ago this would have been a gigantic mismatch, but the WIndies are a team finally on an upward curve (and make no mistake, they have left themselves plenty of room for improvement), whilst Australia are a shadow of their former self since a spate of retirements, none more so than that of Glenn McGrath.

The WIndies batting still looks fragile and overly reliant on Chanderpaul, but Chanderpaul recovered from being floored by a Brett Lee bouncer to hit another century. He received little support - Sarwan, the next best West Indian batsman - having been dismissed cheaply the previous evening, other than a century stand with Runako Morton and a cameo from Bravo. At one stage, he watched from the other end as 4 wickets fell for 10 runs as the tail crumpled around him, but with only Fidel Edwards and the wonderfully named Jaggernauth for company he managed to eek out nearly another 5 runs to leave the WIndies still 119 runs behind.

In recent years the WIndies would have crumbled, but this lot are made of slightly sterner stuff, or rather aren't quite so flimsy - they recent won a test match abroad for the first time in years - and led by Daren Powell and the irrepressible Fidel Edwards they roared back.

Ricky Ponting is a class act with the bat, still for my money the best batsman in the world as he demonstrated yet again in the first innings when he rescued the Convicts, but if you can get an early wicket and go after him early, the Aussies are vulnerable. With Langer retired and flat-track bully Hayden injured, it was the unfamiliar pairing of Jacques and Katich, but Edwards had Jacques edging behind and the WIndies had their tails up. There is no more exciting sight in sport than a fast bowler with his tail him up and a collapse on. It wasn't just Fidel Edwards, Daren Powell was threatening at the other end and had Ponting well caught at slip by Bravo to the obvious jubilation of all involved. All of a sudden Sabina Park was rocking. Edwards roared in to have Flintoff's bunny Katich trapped so plumb lbw the batsman should have walked and then Powell got one through Hussey's bat and pad to castle him, and all of a sudden the Aussies were reeling at 12/4.

Nightwatchman Mitchell Johnson survived until the close, but only by edging one between 4th slip and gully for 4, but the WIndies will know if they can get him early tomorrow its Krusty the Clown next in, followed by Haddin, who is no Gilchrist.

The chances are, the Aussies grind out a lead and Symonds takes the game away from the WIndies, but an evening session just sows the seeds of doubt so that you can start to dream what might happen and to remind you what a fantastic sport cricket is.




Ricky Ponting is still a class act, as he demonstrated in his first innings ton, although apparently he had some unconvincing moments, but with flat-track bully Hayden injured and Langer retired the Aussies have issues with their openers.
 
I've just seen the replay of Chanderpaul being struck by Lee, and fair play to him for getting up and going on to his hundred. It seems to me that he has been around forever but he is still relatively young, and can surely add to his 18 Test centuries.

I think you are right about Ponting and IMO the next best is the much maligned Jacques Kallis. The convict attack does seem somewhat bereft without McGrath & Warne, and they don't seem to have a class spinner in the locker, unless Stuart MacGill recovers from his various troubles.

Agree with your assessment of bully boy Hayden, and we shall have the pleasure of another bully in Saffer captain Graeme Smith this summer. A typical one dimensional captain that only South Africa seem capable of producing.
 
A good first day from the W.Indies in the first test. Hopefully the rain that brought a premature end to the first day is not too disruptive over the next 4 days as it would be fantastic if they could square the series.

The next year leading up to the ashes is going to be interesting seeing how the convicts cope without Mcgrath, Warne and Gilchrist. The seem to be struggling to find the right bowling line up at the moment.
 
Rain saves convicts and Coco the clown gets controversial early reprieve.

Why can't it ever be rain thwarts Aussies and specialist fielder gets dodgy decision against him?

Apparently the pitch is a bit spicy, might watch some of this one (either side of England's 20-20 game).
 
Rain saves convicts and Coco the clown gets controversial early reprieve.

Why can't it ever be rain thwarts Aussies and specialist fielder gets dodgy decision against him?

Apparently the pitch is a bit spicy, might watch some of this one (either side of England's 20-20 game).


I know you dont rate him, but he has been making some good contributions at number 6 for the past year. Im happy for him to continue to do so for the next 12 months so he avoids being dropped. A batting line up with him at 6, no Gilchrist at 7 or Warne at 8 certainly lacks depth.
 
Hopefully this will be a decent contest. Even if the Aussies only make 250 I still think they'll get a 1st innings lead, unless Shiv can produce some magic and get some decent support.

Shocking decision by umpire Benson not giving Symonds out. With Howard Webb's poor officiating in Euro 2008 last night it was a bad day for English officials!
 
as a youngster growing up the windies were one of the best teams ive ever seen. viv richards, joel garner et al. so its good to see them getting some credability back after the last few years.
 
Aussies all out for 251 but the Windies are wobbling on 70/3. Chanderpaul and the promising Marshall at the crease, hopefully the Windies can get a score of at least 200+ to make the match competitive, so much depends on Chanderpaul.
 
I like the way Chris Gayle was talking about how there were runs in this pitch if you are prepared to stick it out, play yourself in and graft for the runs. Yeah righto Chris, that's just your style!
 
Australia 330-3 at the close on day three, 365 on. Even if Michael Clarke had been dismissed at the end of the day, as he could have been, it's still been very much Australia's day, and their series as well. The WIndies are getting better, but unless their batsmen can start replicating the application of Chanderpaul, they will remain susceptible to poor first-innings totals.
 
Back
Top