In what order would you rate the players in central positions?

[DTS]

We seem to have really depth this season and I am pretty happy with any combo we put out as I rate them all.

However if you had to put them in order how you would you go.

Central Defence
Barker
Phillips
Moshni
Coughlan
Prosser

Midfield
Timlin
Grant
Kalala
Ferdinand
Sawyer

Attack
Dickinson
Harris
Corr
Mosnhi
Sturrock
Crawford.

 

[markw]

i'm actually struggling to pick for midfield which i guess is a good thing
Defence :barker and philips
Attack : dickinson corr
Midfield: any

 

[Norwichshrimper]

Central Defence
Barker
Coughlan
Mohsni
Phillips
Prosser
Midfield
Ferdinand
Grant
Kalala
Sawyer
Timlin

Attack
Corr
Crawford
Dickinson
Harris
Mohsni
Sturrock

That was easy, next one please....I'm gonna walk in to MENSA

 

[Southend Neil]

Central defence:

Barker
Mohsni
Phillips
Coughlan
Prosser

Midfield:

Timlin
Ferdinand
Sawyer
Grant
Kalala

Attack:

Corr
Mohsni
Harris
Dickinson
Sturrock
Crawford

 

[IloveShrimp]

Central defence:

Barker
Phillips
Mohsni
Coughlan
Prosser

Midfield:

Timlin
Ferdinand
Sawyer
Grant
Kalala

Attack:
Mohsni
Dickinson
Harris
Sturrock
Crawford
Corr (he is injured place 2 otherwise if playing like last season)

 

[Frankie the half breed]

Centre Defence:
Barker
Mohsni
Phillips
Coughlan
Prosser

Centre Mid:
Timlin
Grant
Ferdinand
Sawyer
Kalala

Attack:
Corr
Mohsni
Dickinson
Harris
Sturrock
Crawford

 

[OldBlueLady]

Mohsni is a defender which is why I'm placing him in the defence bracket here!

Centre Defence:
Barker
Mohsni
Phillips
Coughlan
Prosser

Centre Mid:
Timlin
Grant
Kalala
Ferdinand
Sawyer


Attack:
Dickinson
Harris
Corr
Sturrock
Crawford

 

[southend4life]

Centre Defence:
Phillips
Barker
Mohsni
Coughlan
Prosser

Centre Mid:
Timlin
Sawyer
Grant
Kalala
Ferdinand

Attack:
Dickinson
Harris
Corr
Crawford
Sturrock

 

[JoshC]

Central Defence
Barker
Coughlan
Mohsni
Phillips
Prosser
Midfield
Ferdinand
Grant
Kalala
Sawyer
Timlin

Attack
Corr
Crawford
Dickinson
Harris
Mohsni
Sturrock

That was easy, next one please....I'm gonna walk in to MENSA

Er i'll assume this is :net:

 

[Jedi Shrimper]

Centre Defence:
Barker
Phillips
Mohsni
Coughlan
Prosser

Centre Mid:
Grant
Timlin
Ferdinand
Kalala
Sawyer

Attack:
Corr
Harris
Dickinson
Sturrock
Mohsni
Crawford

 

[DTS]

Suprised the amount of people that rate Moshni over Phillips...

 

[Ricky Otto]

This midfield is impossible, I think my order would change week in week out. You could make arguements for all of them! I think on top form for footballing ability Ferdinand and Sawyer, with Ferdinand taking defensive duties. But Grant is so good in this league, clever, wins so many free kicks and gets in the oppositions face. Timlin is looking impressive and is def a man you want on the field when the chips are down, so impressed with him last week, always wanting the ball. Kalala has really impressed in a short time too! If he comes straight in and plays like this he could easlily improve over the season and be a regular. So hard, even in the space of time it took to type this i'm having second thoughts

 

[Norwichshrimper]

Er i'll assume this is :net:

I thought he meant alphabetical order :smile:

 

[Rob1920]

Selection will probably be made easier in Jan when Timlin goes. Not that I want him to, but can't see any way he will stay regardless of how much he likes it here. It will be Josh Simpson all over again. He's under contract with Swindon whilst earning rave reviews with us. He'll either get called back there or sold to the highest bidder, which won't be us.

Sorry to wander off topic there but thought it was kind of relevent..

 

[rlb999]

Form comes into it too.
Ferdinand is a good player, but not on great form currently.
Grant is arguably the best midfielder we have, but is playing below his potential and I think needs a move to reignite his career.
Kalala probably isn't the best player we have, but the whole team looks so much more solid when he's sat in front of the back 4.
Mohsni is off his t*ts most of the time and could be a matchwinner or liability wherever he plays on the field, depending on his mood.

 

[tice_18]

Central Defence
Phillips
Barker
Moshni
Prosser
Coughlan

Midfield
Kalala
Sawyer
Grant
Timlin
Ferdinand


Attack
Corr
Harris
Dickinson
Mosnhi
Sturrock
Crawford

Midfield is so tough to choose though, all quality players who would walk straight into the first XI of most L2 sides.