Question Who would you rather have - Hall vs Moussa

[DTS]

I remember being a bit gutted when Francky Moussa left in the summer. Only really his departure and Simon Francis's bothered me.

However I think the form and general ability of Ryan Hall now he seems to have settled in has been a breath of fresh air and is probably the reason why were flying as high as we are.

Given the opportunity to have Francky back in place of Hall would you take him or not. Forget Halls pending court case - purely on what the offer the side.

Im going Hall. Love his pace, great crosser and just makes things happen more than Moussa for me.

 

[EastStandBlue]

In actual fact, if we were to continue with this quasi-451/433 system, then Moussa in Grant's position would've been a joy to behold.

It depends entirely on what you're looking for, to be honest. As a left-winger, I think Hall probably edges it because he's quick and has a consistent delivery from wide positions. Moussa, on the other hand, was far better when he was played in his natural position and ran the show against Walsall toward the end of last season when played in that position. Moussa's also the better all-round footballer, IMO.

 

[Norwichshrimper]

In actual fact, if we were to continue with this quasi-451/433 system, then Moussa in Grant's position would've been a joy to behold.

It depends entirely on what you're looking for, to be honest. As a left-winger, I think Hall probably edges it because he's quick and has a consistent delivery from wide positions. Moussa, on the other hand, was far better when he was played in his natural position and ran the show against Walsall toward the end of last season when played in that position. Moussa's also the better all-round footballer, IMO.

Absolutely - if you are looking for a left winger then it's Hall - of you want a Central Midfielder then it's Moussa : I have voted for Hall as we have **** all else in that position and are reasonably covered in the middle

 

[Kent Shrimper]

I will be shot down here, but i never saw what all the fuss was about with regards to Moussa. Shows how little i know but he never excited me.

 

[Shrimper2thecore]

Impossible to call mate. On the left wing, Hall.

I alwasy wanted Moussa in the middle, so would want them both in the side

 

[Eastblack]

I will say Hall. In general I think he's more of a handfull

 

[Beefy]

I will be shot down here, but i never saw what all the fuss was about with regards to Moussa. Shows how little i know but he never excited me.

Same here.

 

[C C Csiders]

I will say Hall. In general I think he's more of a handfull

Thank you Mr Justice Eastblack for the prosecution.

 

[Yorkshire Blue]

Both!

Whilst they both played on the left (although capable of also playing on the right) they had different roles: Hall's a winger, whereas Moussa is a midfielder. They'd actually balance each other out quite well in a 4-4-2 with Hall pushing on and Moussa tucking in. Better still have Hall on the left and the measured passing of Moussa in the centre feeding him.

 

[WESTY_SUFC]

V tough one. While i really like Hall and think he is a match winner we have never seen Moussa at this level so i cant decide to be honest

 

[Eastblack]

Thank you Mr Justice Eastblack for the prosecution.

Ha! Yes, sorry that was unfortunate wording. I meant on the pitch, I wasn't making comment on his extra curricular activities.

 

[leeblue]

correct me if im wrong but hall has 14/15 assists this season already, hall for me, moooooooooooooooooooooooooosa always seemed reluctant to release the ball.

 

[OldBlueLady]

I will be shot down here, but i never saw what all the fuss was about with regards to Moussa. Shows how little i know but he never excited me.

Unsurprisingly to some, I never saw it neither. I've gone for Hall, much more enthusiastic and more of a team player, Moussa was always a bit too selfish/short sighted for my liking.

 

[davewebbsbrain]

I will be shot down here, but i never saw what all the fuss was about with regards to Moussa. Shows how little i know but he never excited me.

I agree 100% with you on this

 

[borientater]

At least hall plays with a smile on his face !

 

[Frankie the half breed]

Hard choice, Ryan Hall is quality he can only keep improving. Gets goals, gets assists, great runner great passer.
I wouldn't get rid of Hall for Moussa to come in, but I did love Moussa thought he was a great player still so young too. I'd love Hall left wing and Moussa centre mid next to him.

 

[superblue24]

How can you compare two players with completely different styles of play? I voted Moussa simply because I feel he was a better all-round player and was generally involved all game. Hall tends to drift in and out of games a little.

Moussa is a Championship player and Hall is L2.....Whilst Hall can roast a few at this level, could he do it in the CH?

 

[OldBlueLady]

How can you compare two players with completely different styles of play? I voted Moussa simply because I feel he was a better all-round player and was generally involved all game. Hall tends to drift in and out of games a little.

Moussa is a Championship player and Hall is L2.....Whilst Hall can roast a few at this level, could he do it in the CH?

Moussa is not a Championship player otherwise he'd be making Leicester's 1st team regularly. He's a good L1 player which I think Hall could be too.

 

[Rayleigh boy]

Moussa is not a Championship player otherwise he'd be making Leicester's 1st team regularly. He's a good L1 player which I think Hall could be too.

you really don't like him do you ?

fair enough but the best young footballer of the Tilson era ..... can't really forget the goal at Col U -

mind you if wanted to watcha bog standard not terribly good L1 midfielder going no-where then theres always Alan MacCormWHACK -

 

[OldBlueLady]

you really don't like him do you ?

fair enough but the best young footballer of the Tilson era ..... can't really forget the goal at Col U -

mind you if wanted to watcha bog standard not terribly good L1 midfielder going no-where then theres always Alan MacCormWHACK -

I don't dislike him, just never got what made him so special to all the bright boys on here. Always looked too cool/disinterested/non plussed and was definitely selfish on the ball. Plus he came to us from West Ham of course.