Magnum Ratings

[Magnum PI]

Flahavan - 7 (Did enough and rarely tested but handled some difficult low shots and crosses)
Mulgrew - 6 (Better coming forward than defending but some shoddy passing at times)
Francis - 8 (Getting better each game)
Barrett - 7 (More solid defensive display)
Clarke - 6 (Average game. Bad slip almost cost us)
Gower - 7 (Poor crossing from set pieces again, but lively at times)
Bailey - 9 (Thank god we had him today !)
Moussa - 7 (Excellent first half - non-existent in the second)
Black - 6 (Never really got going, but put some decent balls in)
Walker - 7 (Worked tirelessly and deserved the goal)
Kanu - 4 (Debut to forget - looked poor)

Thoughts?
I thought we played ok in the first half, but we were dreadful in the second. Luton looked quite good at times as they began to dominate the midfield.

 

[canveyshrimper]

When I saw the thread title I thought it was going to be about my favourite ice cream treat. Imagine my disappointment on discovering it was another player ratings thread.:whistling:

 

[OldBlueLady]

I think you're rather harsh in some of your assessments there, fwiw this is how I saw it:

Flavs - 7, confident but what a silly free kick to give away
Francis - 8.5 , composed, hardly put a foot wrong, my MOM
Clarkey - 8, another great performance, he's here he's there etc
Barrett - 7, much better
Mulgrew - 7.5, some lovely touches (is that right? I'm halfway down a bottle of very nice sparkling red and I'm a bit unsure about that word), growing in confidence each time I see him
Black - 7.5, never stopped running, some good work
Moussa - 6.5, a little quiet and lacked confidence
Bailey - 7.5, good but missed Macca, didn't stamp his authority enough for me
Gower - 7.5, a good game, lovely runs and good passing
Walker - 7, not at his best, definitely missed Barney
Robson-Kanu - 6, looked lazy
Subs:
Scannell - 7, looked good when he came on, loads of running
Grant - 6, ineffective really, but not much chance
Hunt - not worth a score, only came on at end because of Grant's injury.

 

[Cricko]

All ratings in other thread now to keep it tidy ...:)