I suppose it depends whether you think Celebs.Have the right to voice as private opinion 0r not.I do,you obviously don't-Anway I notice we both contributed to the Nick Alliker fund.Well done you.Not a fan of any lefty who uses football to virtue signal their nonsense ......Including forums.
Totally agree, its not just what they say, there is a tone of voice that just works.There's something about the voice of a commentator... not all of them have got "it". For TV games, the ones who did (in my opinion, and I'm going back a few years with some of them) were David Coleman, Barry Davies, Gerald Sinstadt, Hugh Johns, Kenneth Wolstenholme (obvs), John Motson, Clive Tyldesely, Peter Drury and Martin Tyler. There were others who were not bad and who almost had "it"... Brian Moore (controversial, as he did get better after a loud, screechy start), Gerry Harrison, Jonathan Pearce (for a brief period soon after he'd started but then for some reason became not good at all) and Peter Brackley.
There are others who have left no impression on me at all, so much so that I can't remember any of their names.
Radio is different... you have to describe everything a way that pictures the scene for the listener. Alan Green on BBC 5 Live - for my mind - is a fabulous commentator because of his knack of describing the action so that you can visualise it pretty clearly in the mind. His voice has just the right level of inflection at the right times, and he transmits just the right amount of excitement. Jim Proudfoot on Talksport isn't bad either.
When I hear the dross served up by other local BBC stations and the buffoons who commentate on their matches... bloody hell they are awful. Neil Kelly and Glenn Speller are both high quality commentators. Victoria Polley is a far better presenter than a commentator and Stuart Smith I'm afraid is not very good at all. And as for the commentary from the away teams on National League TV, blimey, I could do better. Tonight's at Wealdstone was particularly dull and awful.
But Nick Alliker is by far the best radio commentator there is, with the possible exception of Alan Green. He is right up there, has had a fantastic 35 year career and now wants to do something else. Either Glenn or Neil would be decent replacements, but SUFC games without Nick Alliker on commentary just aren't quite the same.
He will be sorely missed.
Well slightly off topic.There's something about the voice of a commentator... not all of them have got "it". For TV games, the ones who did (in my opinion, and I'm going back a few years with some of them) were David Coleman, Barry Davies, Gerald Sinstadt, Hugh Johns, Kenneth Wolstenholme (obvs), John Motson, Clive Tyldesely, Peter Drury and Martin Tyler. There were others who were not bad and who almost had "it"... Brian Moore (controversial, as he did get better after a loud, screechy start), Gerry Harrison, Jonathan Pearce (for a brief period soon after he'd started but then for some reason became not good at all) and Peter Brackley.
There are others who have left no impression on me at all, so much so that I can't remember any of their names.
Radio is different... you have to describe everything a way that pictures the scene for the listener. Alan Green on BBC 5 Live - for my mind - is a fabulous commentator because of his knack of describing the action so that you can visualise it pretty clearly in the mind. His voice has just the right level of inflection at the right times, and he transmits just the right amount of excitement. Jim Proudfoot on Talksport isn't bad either.
When I hear the dross served up by other local BBC stations and the buffoons who commentate on their matches... bloody hell they are awful. Neil Kelly and Glenn Speller are both high quality commentators. Victoria Polley is a far better presenter than a commentator and Stuart Smith I'm afraid is not very good at all. And as for the commentary from the away teams on National League TV, blimey, I could do better. Tonight's at Wealdstone was particularly dull and awful.
But Nick Alliker is by far the best radio commentator there is, with the possible exception of Alan Green. He is right up there, has had a fantastic 35 year career and now wants to do something else. Either Glenn or Neil would be decent replacements, but SUFC games without Nick Alliker on commentary just aren't quite the same.
He will be sorely missed.
Listened to this last night, it's well worth 30 mins of anyone's time.BBC Essex Special - The Voice of the Blues (09/04/2024) - The Voice of the Blues (09/04/2024) - BBC Sounds
BBC Essex is looking back at 35 years of Nick Alliker commentating on Southend United.www.bbc.co.uk
Is anyone else still listening to BBC Essex and the GWR commentary? The commentator is really good. Could he be a replacement for Nick?