Mick
The Ref Aficionado.
He is now old and past it, his recent record in league 1 shows that.
His recent record shows that he was good enough to play 43 times for a club which won a place in the Championship last season.
How many games did you see him play last season ? What role was he performing ?
What have you based your critique on? Simply his age and the number of goals scored, I suspect.
I don't know if he's still up to it or not so I would hold off making dogmatic statements one way or the other.