• Welcome to the ShrimperZone forums.
    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which only gives you limited access.

    Existing Users:.
    Please log-in using your existing username and password. If you have any problems, please see below.

    New Users:
    Join our free community now and gain access to post topics, communicate privately with other members, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and free. Click here to join.

    Fans from other clubs
    We welcome and appreciate supporters from other clubs who wish to engage in sensible discussion. Please feel free to join as above but understand that this is a moderated site and those who cannot play nicely will be quickly removed.

    Assistance Required
    For help with the registration process or accessing your account, please send a note using the Contact us link in the footer, please include your account name. We can then provide you with a new password and verification to get you on the site.

Football Manager research - Phase 1 ratings

JTSB

The Big Dog
Joined
Jan 19, 2007
Messages
4,735
Location
Bexleyheath, Greater London
For those FM fans interested, here are the ratings I have sent off for Phase 1 of the research process for FM 2010.

CA = Current Ability (out of 200); e.g. Cristiano Ronaldo has a CA of 191.
PA = Potential Ability (out of 200); in younger players, negatives used, where -10 = amazing potential and -1 = might as well give up the game.
CR = Current Reputation (out of 200) - used by the game to order squad status for individuals and decide whether a player is happy to stay put or wants to 'move to a bigger club', e.g. Cristiano Ronaldo has a CR of 190.
Change = change in CA/PA/CR in particular player since last research phase in January 2009.

Code:
                                   [B]CA     Change     PA       Change      CR     Change     Consist.[/B]
[B][U]Star Players (CA 101-115)[/U][/B]
1    Dervite, Dorian[B]*[/B]             113       [B][COLOR="Red"]-2[/COLOR][/B]        -8        0         96      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+11[/COLOR][/B]         15
2    Clarke, Peter                108       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+2[/COLOR][/B]       115        0         98       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+3[/COLOR][/B]         16
3    Barnard, Lee                 106       [B][COLOR="Red"]-4[/COLOR][/B]       118       [B][COLOR="Red"]-7[/COLOR][/B]         94       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+4[/COLOR][/B]         12
4    McCormack, Alan              103       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+4[/COLOR][/B]       115       [B][COLOR="Red"]-3[/COLOR][/B]         93      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+18[/COLOR][/B]         16
5    Christophe, Jean-François    101       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+2[/COLOR][/B]       130     [B][COLOR="Lime"]was -7[/COLOR][/B]       93       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+7[/COLOR][/B]         14


[B][U]First Team Players (CA 81-100)[/U][/B]
6    Barrett, Adam                100       [B][COLOR="Red"]-5[/COLOR][/B]       112       [B][COLOR="Red"]-3[/COLOR][/B]         94       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+4[/COLOR][/B]         15
7    Mildenhall, Steve             97       [B][COLOR="Red"]-7[/COLOR][/B]       103       [B][COLOR="Red"]-7[/COLOR][/B]         91       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+6[/COLOR][/B]         12
8    Francis, Simon                96       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+1[/COLOR][/B]       115       [B][COLOR="Red"]-3[/COLOR][/B]         91       [B][COLOR="Red"]-4[/COLOR][/B]          9
9    Robinson, Theo[B]*[/B]               95       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+5[/COLOR][/B]       120      [B][COLOR="Red"]was -7[/COLOR][/B]      90      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+10[/COLOR][/B]         12
10   Freedman, Dougie              94      [B][COLOR="Red"]-15[/COLOR][/B]       127      [B]PEAK[/B]        94       [B][COLOR="Red"]-9[/COLOR][/B]         11
11   Grant, Anthony                93       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+4[/COLOR][/B]       115        0         90       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+7[/COLOR][/B]         10
12   Moussa, Franck                92       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+6[/COLOR][/B]        -8      [B][COLOR="Lime"]was -7[/COLOR][/B]      90      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+25[/COLOR][/B]         13
13   Revell, Alex                  91       [B][COLOR="Red"]-7[/COLOR][/B]       100      [B][COLOR="Red"]-10[/COLOR][/B]         88       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+4[/COLOR][/B]         12
14   Laurent, Francis              90       [B][COLOR="Red"]-6[/COLOR][/B]       115       [B][COLOR="Red"]-2[/COLOR][/B]         85       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+2[/COLOR][/B]         10
15   Walker, James                 88        0       110       [B][COLOR="Red"]-5[/COLOR][/B]         84        0          9
16   Sankofa, Osei                 87       [B][COLOR="Red"]-1[/COLOR][/B]       115       [B][COLOR="Red"]-5[/COLOR][/B]         88        0         11
17   Betsy, Kevin                  86        0        95      [B][COLOR="Red"]-15[/COLOR][/B]         90       [B][COLOR="Red"]-3[/COLOR][/B]          8
18   Herd, Johnny                  85        0        -7        0         77      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+34[/COLOR][/B]         11
19   Joyce, Ian                    85        0       118       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+8[/COLOR][/B]         78       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+8[/COLOR][/B]         14
20   Scannell, Damien              83       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+4[/COLOR][/B]       110       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+5[/COLOR][/B]         80      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+35[/COLOR][/B]          8


[B][U]Reserve Team Players (CA 0-70)[/U][/B]
21   O'Keefe, Stuart               75       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+4[/COLOR][/B]        -7        0         65       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+5[/COLOR][/B]         11
22   Calver, Craig                 62       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+2[/COLOR][/B]        -7        0         56      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+21[/COLOR][/B]         11
23   Masters, Clark                59        0        -6        0         59      [B][COLOR="Red"]-11[/COLOR][/B]         14

[B][U]Youth Team Players[/U][/B]
     Abalimba, Medi                52      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+10[/COLOR][/B]        -6        0         52      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+22[/COLOR][/B]          9
     Adeyinka, Tashan              50      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+12[/COLOR][/B]        -6        0         50      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+20[/COLOR][/B]          8
     Morris, Jack                  47      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+12[/COLOR][/B]        -5      [B][COLOR="Lime"]was -4[/COLOR][/B]      47      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+27[/COLOR][/B]          8
     Whittaker, Callum             47      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+17[/COLOR][/B]        -5      [B][COLOR="Red"]was -6[/COLOR][/B]      47      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+27[/COLOR][/B]         10
     Hazell, Justin                46        0        -6      [B][COLOR="Lime"]was -5[/COLOR][/B]      46      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+11[/COLOR][/B]         10
     Rieck, Gordon                 45        0        -5      [B][COLOR="Lime"]was -4[/COLOR][/B]      45      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+15[/COLOR][/B]         14
     Dennis, Jamie                 44      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+14[/COLOR][/B]        -5      [B][COLOR="Lime"]was -4[/COLOR][/B]      44      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+24[/COLOR][/B]          9
     Asante, Kyle                  42       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+6[/COLOR][/B]        -5        0         42      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+22[/COLOR][/B]          7
     McDonald, Nathan              42        0        -4      [B][COLOR="Red"]was -5[/COLOR][/B]      42      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+17[/COLOR][/B]          7
     Byrne, Ricky                  41        0        -4      [B][COLOR="Red"]was -5[/COLOR][/B]      41      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+29[/COLOR][/B]          8
     Owinga, John                  41      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+11[/COLOR][/B]        -4      [B][COLOR="Red"]was -5[/COLOR][/B]      41      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+21[/COLOR][/B]          8
     Crawford, Harry               40        0        -5        0         40      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+10[/COLOR][/B]          7
     Osifuwa, Adetayo              40       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+1[/COLOR][/B]        -5        0         40      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+10[/COLOR][/B]         13
     Jones, Ronnie                 38       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+3[/COLOR][/B]        -4      [B][COLOR="Lime"]was -3[/COLOR][/B]      38      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+23[/COLOR][/B]         11
     Reynolds, Duran               38       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+8[/COLOR][/B]        -5        0         38      [B][COLOR="Lime"]+18[/COLOR][/B]          9
     James-Lewis, Merrick          35        0        -4      [B][COLOR="Red"]was -5[/COLOR][/B]      35       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+5[/COLOR][/B]          9
     Milner, Marcus                31       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+1[/COLOR][/B]        -4        0         31       [B][COLOR="Lime"]+6[/COLOR][/B]         11
* denotes loan players.

Average CA of top 16 players (with loanees) = 97.12 (just within the bracket for a side finishing 5th-9th in L1 in 08/09.)
Average CA of top 16 players (without loanees) = 94.81


Youth team players raises reflect:
1) Success of youth team in winning the Youth Alliance league last season.
2) A number of those players having attracting the interest of and having trials with Premiership clubs.
3) My first attempt at really rating those youth players having watched them a fair bit more last season. The 30s and 35s that they were all sat on before were generic ratings that I gave to them all because I had yet to see them play properly.


CR raises reflect:
1) My first attempt at really rating CRs having previously left values given by previous researcher in and giving youth team players generic 20s or 30s for CR.
2) With most youth team players, CR=CA, as seems to be the practice with a lot of other researchers.

Now awaiting feedback from Sports Interactive, who will tell me whether they feel I've overrated, underrated or got it spot on.
 
Top